Read the reviews carefully to extract the suggestions for revision and list them in the Excel file. Extract the suggestions from the reviewers' and editors' comments You could label the 4 columns as, “Reviewer,” “Suggestions,” “Response,” “Status.” Widening the columns and wrapping the text makes it much more readable, especially for the two columns in the middle.ģ. Create an Excel file to list the revisionsĬreate an Excel file with four columns in which to list the reviewers’ suggestions for revision. If you are unsure, you could make an inquiry to the editor or ask a more experienced colleague to read the letter for you.Ģ. Iii.) Outright acceptance or Accept as is, where changes are not required, but might be suggested. Ii.) Conditional acceptance, where you are asked to make minor changes and I.) Reject without an invitation to re-submit or outright rejection Other possible responses you could receive from the editor include: Read the letter from the editor carefully and make sure that you have indeed received a request to revise and resubmit your paper. My method consists of ten easy-to-follow steps. Over time, I have developed a straightforward approach to these requests. To date, I have successfully completed 20 requests to revise extensively and resubmit. Once all revisions are approved, you will receive an acceptance email from Manuscript Review through the TigerPrints ETD portal, and you are FINISHED - your work is done.When I submit an article to a top journal, often, the best possible outcome I can hope for is that the editors will invite me to respond to the reviewers’ comments and resubmit the article. It’s perfectly legit to get hands-on help, and we understand deadline anxiety. If you receive revision instructions that are unclear, or if you have problems making requested revisions and can’t find help within your department, please contact the Manuscript Review Office staff via email at or stop by the office in E-106 Martin Hall. Hyperlinks and URLs are inconsistent (black, no underline preferred, but colored links are fine as long as you’ve used them consistently)ĭon't forget: Manuscript Review staff can help.Issues dealing with wide or oversized tables and illustrations.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |